The rule in plain words
- Different sides?The vessel with the wind on the port side keeps out of the way of the other.
- Same side?The vessel to windward keeps out of the way of the vessel to leeward.
- Cannot tell the other's side?If you have wind on the port side, see the other vessel to windward and cannot determine her side with certainty, keep out of her way.
- What is the windward side?It is the side opposite to that on which the mainsail is carried; for a square-rigged vessel, opposite the side carrying the largest fore-and-aft sail.
Before you read on: what would you do?
When two sailing vessels have the wind on different sides, which vessel keeps out of the way?
Frequent mistakes
Wrong: "With different wind sides, neither vessel has priority."
Right: The vessel with the wind on the port side keeps out of the way of the other.
Wrong: "With the same wind side, the leeward vessel keeps out."
Right: The windward vessel keeps out of the way; the other vessel is to leeward.
Wrong: "If I cannot tell the other's side, I maintain my course."
Right: With wind on port and the other vessel to windward, keep out when her side is uncertain.
Exam keys & interpretation
- "Different sides" does not mean port for both: identify which vessel has the wind on the port side.
- Same side: do not choose by port or starboard; first identify which vessel is to windward.
- Port wind + other vessel to windward + uncertainty activates paragraph (a)(iii): keep out.
How to read it
Read the rule in two steps: compare the wind sides; if they match, identify the windward and leeward vessels.
The windward definition avoids judging by appearance: check where the mainsail, or largest fore-and-aft sail, is carried.
Key points
- Different sides → wind on port: keep out of the way.
- Same side → windward vessel keeps clear of the leeward vessel.
- Port wind + other vessel to windward + side uncertain → keep out.
- Windward = opposite the mainsail; square-rigged → opposite the largest fore-and-aft sail.
Test your knowledge
3 questions to check it. Pick an answer to see why.
When both sailing vessels have the wind on the same side, which vessel keeps out?
Official text
Reviewed by Ramon Curto, Nautical teacher at IECNPC · Last reviewed:
